Managing Low and High Performers The Playbook Everyone Is Looking For
Let’s be real: managing people is hard. Managing people well? Even harder. Because on any given team, you’re not just managing tasks. You’re managing energy, personalities, pace, pressure, politics, burnout, expectations, and your own growth in the middle of it all.
Some team members light things up. Others keep missing the mark. And you? You’re supposed to carry the whole equation while still hitting your own targets.
Let’s take the pressure down. This isn’t about being the “perfect” people manager. This is about learning how to lead, across performance levels, with clarity, trust, and accountability.
Before You Manage People, Understand the Playing Field
Before you start labeling team members as “high” or “low” performers, pause and zoom out.
Great people management starts with situational awareness. Not just who you’re managing, but where.
1. Understand the company culture, really.
Not just what’s in the employee handbook. Ask:
What actually gets rewarded?
Who gets promoted, and why?
What do successful people actually do here?
There are written rules, and then there are unwritten ones. Learn both. Align accordingly
2. Consider the diversity of your team.
You’re likely managing a blend of:
Different generations (Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X)
Varied cultural, religious, educational, and socio-economic backgrounds
People with visible and invisible differences, including gender identity, sexual orientation, or disability
One-size-fits-all leadership doesn’t work. You’ll need to adapt without lowering the bar
3. Be honest about the company’s tolerance for boldness.
Many orgs say they want candor and courage, but punish it when it’s inconvenient.
Lead with integrity, but lead strategically. Learn when to speak up, and how much truth your environment can actually handle. And don’t become the one who owns all the problems in the room. Find mentors, observe outcomes, and learn the unofficial playbook.
Start by Knowing Who’s Who
Every team has a mix. Your job isn’t to make everyone the same. It’s to meet people where they are, and move them forward.
You’re likely managing:
High Performers: Driven, proactive, consistent, curious
Core Performers: Steady, reliable, but not stretching
Low Performers: Struggling with output, consistency, or mindset
Each group needs something different from you.
Managing High Performers (Without Losing Them)
High performers are your competitive edge, and your ticket to the next level. But managing them well means walking a fine line. They usually know their value, have their own standards, and they’ll leave if they feel:
Overlooked
Undervalued
Overworked
Unchallenged
What to do:
Stretch them without burning them Complexity > Quantity. Challenge them, don’t drown them.
Put them in the spotlight Let them present. Nominate them for exposure. Make sure they’re seen.
Coach them to share their methods Help them pass on knowledge in a way that also supports their own growth. Frame it as leadership development.
Build their next chapter with them Ask: “What would make you want to stay here another two years?” Then help make that happen.
🔴Important: High performers need to feel valued and appreciated, but you must also pay attention to what example they’re setting for the rest of the team. Beware of toxic or unethical top performers. Don’t let contribution blind you to character. A high performer who spreads toxicity will slowly corrode team culture. Don’t hesitate to let them go.
Managing Low Performers (Without Losing Yourself)
Low performers are tricky. Their impact isn’t just their own lack of results, they can drain the momentum of the entire team. They’re often more visible to leadership and create pressure that can ripple across your performance.
Not every low performer is a lost cause. But managing them well is a true leadership test.
Start by understanding the root:
Is it a skill gap? Is it coachable or not?
Is it a process gap?
What to do:
Document everything in real-time Use a shared tracker. Make goals visible. Eliminate ambiguity.
Frame support as theirs, not yours “I want to help you win” lands better than “You’re failing and this is your last shot.”
Be clear, without being cruel Clarity doesn’t need to be aggressive. But it must be unmissable.
Get People/HR involved early Loop them in from yellow flag to red zone, not just when things go south.
Manage the team narrative Pressure on one person affects the whole room. Be smart in how you communicate. Prevent victim-playing, whispering, and gossip.
Keep your manager aligned No surprises. Keep skip-level conversations tight and transparent.
🔴 Watch out for this pattern: Some low performers weaponize sympathy. They spin the story, blame the pressure, or position you as the villain. Protect your own narrative, professionally and proactively. And make sure the rest of the team understands the standards, not just the story.
Managing the Middle (Core Performers)
This group is your engine, the backbone of your team. They’re often overlooked but carry most of the day-to-day output and stability.
And yes, even on high-performing teams, there’s a natural curve. You’ll always have:
A few top performers
A large middle majority
A few trailing behind
What to do:
Spot the ones ready to rise Give them stretch projects. Talk about career moves. Support their growth.
Watch for quiet decline Not all disengagement is loud. Notice subtle shifts.
Re-recruit them Make sure they know they matter. Small recognition goes a long way.
Explore what’s next Ask: Do they want to move up? Lateral shift? Different function? Keep it personal.
This group is also easily swayed by both high and low performers. Your leadership here is what solidifies or fractures team culture.
Leading in a Performance-Driven Environment? Do This Differently
Managing a sales, growth, or marketing team? These environments run on numbers, speed, and pressure. That calls for specific leadership tactics.
1. Build a tracker that includes soft and hard metrics.
Track:
Revenue, output, conversion rates
Reliability, collaboration, mindset
Track individuals and team-wide. Look for patterns
2. Use that data to guide team-wide interventions.
Spot the trend → build the solution. Try:
Playbooks
Peer learning
Group coaching Save 1:1s for nuance. Solve scale with scale
3. Group people and run a gap analysis
Interview top, middle, and low performers. Observe differences. Replicate what works. Build systems that raise the bar for everyone.
Reminder: You don’t need to turn everyone into a “top performer.” Raise the floor. Set a bar. Respect the curve. Just make sure everyone’s growing from where they are.
4. Separate coaching potential from culture mismatch.
Some people can grow with support. Others are simply in the wrong seat. Move with discernment, not guilt.
Annual conversations, development plans, and fresh hires all help you lead with momentum, not guilt
5. Decide fast. Act kindly. Move clearly
Support is essential. But dragging decisions is not. If someone isn’t going to make it, move them. Internally if possible, externally if needed
The Biggest Mistake Managers Make
It’s not missing a KPI. It’s not a tough conversation gone sideways. It’s this:
Spending all your energy on low performers, ignoring your high ones, and assuming your core will stay steady.
That’s not leadership. That’s babysitting fire drills.
The best managers:
Spot the highs
Coach the middle
Deal swiftly with the lows
And create a culture where everyone knows what great looks like
You don’t lead by being perfect. You lead by being intentional.
Know your team. Know your company. Build your systems. Keep your standards. Coach with care. And move with clarity.
Final Thought
The biggest mistake managers make? Spending all their energy on the lows and forgetting the highs.” Every overwhelmed people leader ever
Being a great manager isn’t about fixing everyone. It’s about leading everyone, with standards, structure, and serious clarity.
Your team is a mix. Your job isn’t to make them the same. It’s to meet them where they are, and move them forward.
Managing people well starts with managing yourself well: your energy, your focus, your boundaries.
This is the playbook. Use it well, and make it yours.
🤔 Which performer level (high, core, low) have you been unintentionally neglecting? What’s one shift you’ll make this week to reset?
📌 Know a manager juggling people pressure? Tag them or pass this along. The real playbook deserves to be shared.
♻️ If this gave you a framework or a “wait, I’ve done that” moment, share it forward. Better managers build better teams.
If this hit home and you think its' time for new conversation, let’s talk and if you enjoyed this piece, you’ll love our weekly Wednesday drop, real, bold, unfiltered, practical and actionable conversations you didn't know you need it, straight to your inbox. Sign Up Today
